Peanut Butter and Jelly Trick
Make a peanut butter jar trade places with a jelly jar! And more!

Peanut Butter and Jelly Trick


Make a peanut butter jar trade places with a jelly jar!


Ages 13 and up   Level 2

Demo Video

Easy switch! And works with jelly or OTHER items!


What could be better for kids' shows than doing a trick with kids' favorite food- peanut butter and jelly!
This trick should definitely be a part of your show!

The effect goes like this:
Show your audience a jar of peanut butter and a jar of jelly.
A red cover is placed over each jar.
At your command the peanut butter and jelly jars switch places!
And then switch again!
The peanut butter and jelly continue to fool the audience, switching places unexpectedly and getting the audience loudly involved.
Great for kids' parties!

Lots of fun with adults too!
Use this great trick to switch the peanut butter with ANY small object, like a deck of cards!
Use if for trade shows, sales meetings, ministry magic, etc.

This effect comes with illustrated step by step instructions.
The trick uses a real, unopened jelly jar, which you must supply.
This product is compatible with most popular jelly brands right off the shelf.

By the way, the white specks you see on the red covers in the demo video are reflections of the lighting we used when we shot the video.
The red covers are solid red- no white specks.

What You Get

Here's what you'll get:

  • Peanut Butter and Jelly set
  • easy printed instructions

You supply an ordinary unopened real jelly jar.

Tips & Ideas

Performance Ideas

Use this effect at a trade show or business meeting.
You can switch the peanut butter jar with any other small object such as a company's product, a stack of business cards, small promotional items, etc.

Change the label on the peanut butter jar.
Make a new label for the peanut butter jar so you can represent changing a jar of whatever you want into another item.

Customer Reviews

Hobby Magician
This trick according to my little girl fans is the best trick ever!! So simple to do and worth every cent I paid for it. The nice thing about buying from Peter is that he shows you how to do the trick. This is the best magic store on the internet!!!!!
Reviewed by: (Verified Buyer)  from ID. on 8/20/2015
The routine I do with this product is that I show a jar of jelly and a jar of peanut butter. I cover them both up and ask my audience to remember which is where as I shuffle them from one side of my table to the other. No matter how hard they pay attention they never get it right. I finish by telling my audience that I forgot these are Magic peanut butter and jelly jars and that they must be switching places on their own. I then have them stay stationary, cover them again and then announce that they have been switching on their own the whole time. I absolutely love this product and highly recommend it.
Reviewed by: (Verified Buyer)  from CA. on 6/19/2015

Rewards Points

Buy this item - get 85 Rewards Points!

OTHER ITEMS YOU MIGHT LIKE: (if there is an arrow to the right, click it to see more items)

Recently Viewed Items

The cookie settings on this website are set to 'allow all cookies' to give you the very best experience. Please click Accept Cookies to continue to use the site.