The American Society for Psychical Research was founded in 1885 to investigate claims involving psychic phenomena and spiritualism.
By the 1920s, the organization had become deeply involved in attempts to determine whether mediums could produce genuine supernatural phenomena under controlled conditions.
Harry Houdini brought a very different kind of expertise to these investigations. As a professional magician, he understood how apparently impossible manifestations could be produced through deception, misdirection and concealed methods.
In 1922, Scientific American offered a $2,500 prize to a psychic who could demonstrate a genuine physical psychic manifestation under controlled conditions.
One of the most famous claimants was Boston medium Mina Crandon, who performed under the name "Margery." Houdini served on the committee investigating her claims.
Margery convinced some investigators that her phenomena were genuine. Houdini strongly disagreed. He became one of her most determined critics, arguing that her demonstrations could be explained by trickery.
After extensive testing, the investigating committee concluded that Margery had failed to provide convincing evidence of genuine spirit phenomena. The decision intensified an already bitter disagreement among researchers over whether her manifestations were real.
This envelope was mailed from the American Society for Psychical Research in New York on February 19, 1925 — just eight days after the committee's decision concerning Margery.
It is associated with Walter Franklin Prince, a prominent psychical researcher who, like Houdini, remained skeptical of Margery's claims.
The original letter is no longer with the envelope, so we cannot know exactly what was being discussed. Given the timing and the intense controversy surrounding the Margery investigation, the envelope survives from a particularly significant moment in Houdini's campaign against fraudulent mediumship.
The Margery case created deep divisions among people investigating psychic phenomena. Some researchers believed she possessed genuine supernatural abilities, while others remained convinced that her effects were fraudulent.
Walter Franklin Prince later separated from the American Society for Psychical Research and helped establish the Boston Society for Psychical Research.
Houdini continued his campaign against Margery. He exposed methods he believed she used and demonstrated similar effects before audiences to show that apparently supernatural phenomena could be reproduced by a magician.
This envelope survives from one of the most famous episodes in Houdini's battle with spiritualism.
It connects Houdini with the American Society for Psychical Research, Walter Franklin Prince and the investigation of Mina Crandon at a time when the question of Margery's authenticity had divided researchers.
We cannot know what the missing letter said. But the date and sender place this piece of Houdini's correspondence directly within the period of one of the most controversial psychic investigations of his career.
Explore more original correspondence preserved by Harry Houdini, discover how the collection was found, or see which authentic Houdini envelopes are currently available to collectors.
Magic history is filled with conflicting accounts, uncertain dates, publicity claims, and stories repeated over many years. We make every reasonable effort to present accurate information based on the sources available to us, but historical sources sometimes disagree and new information may come to light. If you have documented information that may help us correct or improve this page, please contact us.